Try the political quiz
+

Filter by author

Narrow down the conversation to these participants:

38 Replies

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...1yr1Y

Yes

 @9ZV3QTFdisagreed…1yr1Y

They have every right to defend their beliefs and territorial claim irregardless of who is right or wrong.

 @9ZTSYQRdisagreed…1yr1Y

Israelis are in every major company, if we ban Israeli companies, we will lose a lot of money in the economy.

 @ISIDEWITHDiscuss this answer...1yr1Y

No

 @9ZV3QTFagreed…1yr1Y

If we suspend trade with Israel then we should also suspend trade with the UK until the Northern Irish territory is returned to the Republic of Ireland.

 @9ZTSYQRagreed…1yr1Y

The EU is Israel’s largest trading partner and the prospect of suspending the favourable terms under which that trade takes place is a powerful weapon in the bloc’s arsenal that it may be difficult to get political consensus to use.

 @9ZHKPPSanswered…1yr1Y

Lessen trade but I don’t know to what extent we trade with them. We should stand for morality but not hurt our own economy in the process

 @9ZVDPHYanswered…1yr1Y

There are more important issues in Ireland that the government should be focused on. Not a war that has nothing to do with us when we are a neutral country.

 @MG---SwIndependent commented…1yr1Y

It is a genocide in Gaza and Israel is an apartheid state running ethnic cleansing practices for decades. This is about Ireland's integrity, morality and courage, not its neutrality.

 @9ZQ3L99Aontúanswered…1yr1Y

This war never needed to happen, all parties as as guilty as each other. This needs to stop and lives of children to be spared. Not suspend but demand peace

 @MG---SwIndependent commented…1yr1Y

All parties are definitely NOT as guilty as each other. Israel is a colonialist, apartheid state which has been pursuing ethnic cleansing and land-stealing policies for decades and is now committing a genocide, quite openly and brazenly, in front of the whole world and believes it can commit crimes against humanity with impunity. Last night alone, they bombed and killed 3 babies under one from the same family. IDF soldiers brag about their war crimes openly on social media, mocking their victims. The right-wing Israeli government and its ally, the US government have openly threatened innocent…  Read more

 @B42KKF8answered…1yr1Y

if trade with israel were to be suspended then trade with palistine should be suspended as to no show bias towards one side of a conflict were not even involved in

 @B22DPSDSocial Democratsanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, Ireland should cease trade relations with any countries who perpetrate or facilitate war crimes.

 @9ZX76R3answered…1yr1Y

Yes, but because of Israeli oppression of, and discrimination against Palestinians, including those in East Jerusalem and the West Bank. Not just Israel's part in the Israel Hamas war.

 @9ZVN766answered…1yr1Y

It’s not Israel-Hamas, it’s literally Israel committing genocide. Would you call the freedom fighters from the 1916 rising terrorists?

 @9ZV2KYFSocial Democratsanswered…1yr1Y

It is not my desire to unfairly penalise the innocent citizens that are living it what is now know as Isreal, formally known as Palestine.

However, the savagely disproportionate response from Isreal's governing body in their devastating attacks on Gaza cannot go unpunished.

It is up to our globaly community to strive towards peace and prosperity for all, therefore those commit unspeakable acts of violence must held accountable on a global level. So, yes, I do feel that until we have a permanent ceasefire and a conflict free resolution Ireland must suspend trade with Israel.

 @9ZTZRT4Fine Gaelanswered…1yr1Y

no, but we should lessen trade until the trouble has ended. We should stand for morality but not hurt our own economy in the process

 @MG---SwIndependentcommented…1yr1Y

Some things are more important than economics. This is one of them.

 @9ZK6XY6answered…1yr1Y

No because a fair population of Israel is against the war so why should they suffer? & what is happening in Gaza, the reason it started is because Oct 7th 2023 3,000 Hamas leaders came from Gaza kidnapping 1,500 isrealis & killing brutally raping & burning 1,500 additional isrealis Hamas is not innocent, there is no winners in war.

 @9ZJXB9FSocial Democratsanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, Israel are causing a genocide. All trade must cease immediately, otherwise we support them. A two week old newborn went into cardiac arrest and died after hearing a bomb fall. A bomb supplied by the US.

 @B7VP6JNAontúanswered…7mos7MO

we must retain & maintain the triple lock & because we're a neutral country so we don't take sides in a specific war or holds itself as permanently neutral in all future conflicts. This policy means it does not join military alliances and remains impartial, though the specifics can vary, with some engaging in peacekeeping or international development

 @B7VFKXMAontúanswered…7mos7MO

We are a neutral country & we must engage in in peacekeeping or international development as we retain & maintain the triple Lock

 @B7V8N9MSocial Democratsanswered…7mos7MO

we are a nurtrial country we must not partake in the Israel-Hamas conflict but humanatrain aid we can provide

 @B7QKQ64Aontúanswered…7mos7MO

we must chooses not to participate in armed conflicts between other nations, refraining from joining military alliances and maintaining impartiality. Key examples include Switzerland and Austria

 @B7N3YL5Social Democratsanswered…7mos7MO

Yes, they sould also prevent US military flights landing in Shannon and remove Israel war bonds from Ireland

 @B7KYV23answered…7mos7MO

As a neutral country we should be careful as to what we decide to do, as we could potentially become a target

 @B74S7Q5answered…8mos8MO

Ban sale of weapons or bombs or permissiom for these producto to be transportes to Israel vía Ireland. But not all trade

 @B4LP829answered…1yr1Y

Obviously, the killing of civilians is never justified, and it is disrespectful to the people in our history that fought for independence and suffered from colonial empires, aswell as for other countries

 @B3BS5L2answered…1yr1Y

NO Ireland should stop helping Hamas with aid ,till they give back the hostages to Isreal. Ireland should not be helping a terrorist organisation wage war on a democratic country.

 @B2NL5D4answered…1yr1Y

No, but if there is undeniable evidence that the money that Israel make by trading with Ireland goes to funding weapons in the Israel-Hamas conflict then the Irish government should immediately suspend trade with Israel.

 @9ZWW7F8answered…1yr1Y

Yes and they should also hold all people of an Isreali citizenship in Ireland hostage until the war ends

 @9ZVZV4Ganswered…1yr1Y

This is a difficult question with many nuances. Hamas is a terrorist organisation with the goal of destroying Israel. But Israel is committing Domicide in Gaza, making it impossible for the population to live there.

 @9ZVZMYPanswered…1yr1Y

Trade with Israel should ONLY benefit children and vulnerable people living there who are NOT involved with the conflicts. Citizens are still citizens. Palestine should be the priority for any aid provided by Ireland

 @9ZKMLLNanswered…1yr1Y

Depends on who they are trading with, do a huge background search and make sure it’s for good and not bad

 @9ZJ4RLCSocial Democratsanswered…1yr1Y

Yes, with a large emphasis that the October attack is not forgotten but the bloodshed in response has gone on far too long

 @9ZSKYHRanswered…1yr1Y

No, because it would economically disadvantage us, but we should promote Palestinian business and increase aid.

 @9ZQN75Ranswered…1yr1Y

At the beginning I would have said no, but it has been taken too far and I believe it must happen now

 @9ZKWJGDSocial Democratsanswered…1yr1Y

This is not feasible due to Irish trade with Israel falling under the EU-Israel Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Agreement.

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...