Proponents argue that this strategy would bolster national security by minimizing the risk of potential terrorists entering the country. Enhanced screening processes, once implemented, would provide a more thorough assessment of applicants, reducing the likelihood of malicious actors gaining entry. Critics argue that such a policy might inadvertently promote discrimination by broadly categorizing individuals based on their nation of origin rather than specific, credible threat intelligence. It may strain diplomatic relations with the affected countries and potentially harm the perception of the nation enacting the ban, being seen as hostile or prejudiced towards certain international communities. Additionally, genuine refugees fleeing terrorism or persecution in their home countries might be unjustly denied safe haven.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Ideology:
Province:
County:
Region:
Constituency:
Electoral Division:
Civil Parish:
Townland:
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Yes
@9ZDXVF56mos6MO
What about the millions of Irish people who have emigrated around the world over the last 75 years ? They weren't vetted, so why should we vet incoming people, just because we perceive them to be dangerous because if their ethnicity or religion
Yes. But not based on ability to screen for terrorism, it should be based on screening for any history of violent or sexual crimes
@9N6X37412mos12MO
No, living in a high risk country is a reason to immigrate. Our government needs to improve it's ability to screen and implement deportation measures to anyone with a high profile.
@B228G2F5mos5MO
Immigrants should be banned from all countries regardless of whether they’re from Ukraine, Iraq, Somalia, Syria, Israel, etc unless they have been fully screened and cleared
@9ZWFCTX 5mos5MO
There should be more and improved places or centres to screen and vet people. But banning people solely because they are immigrants feels discriminatory
@9ZVZ6FV5mos5MO
No , banning is too far and extreme and not right. had the wrong idea to presume that every immigrant walking in asa terrorist it’s frankly racist but there should be steps to vet and document immigrants to not disregard the fact that it is important to know.
@9ZVTXGTSocial Democrats5mos5MO
I don't like how Irish people see refugees and immigrants as a risk to our society and decide to call them terrorists when they're just looking for a better standard of living
@9NXPTSZ11mos11MO
This is a tricky question as on the one hand yes terrorists must be screened but you can’t abandon those who need the help
@B57532CIndependent1wk1W
No but it must invest in and prioritise security measures to screen out dangerous individuals with urgency
@B4NF5KN4wks4W
No, however, they should be held in camps or government housing and monitored until they are screened.
@B4LP8291mo1MO
If the high risk is as dangerous as going to far right criminals, thugs, etc then that is their decision or the governments decision
the governemnt should do background checks on the people coming into the country regardless of there country of origon
@B42L8BP2mos2MO
Not banned, but closely monitored until it can be guaranteed that they are not carrying out a covert operation which could endanger civilians
@B42KKF82mos2MO
no the government shouldnt just ban immigrants from high risk countries on the spot. they should improve their screening processes whilst intaking immigrants at the same time
@B3YVXKB2mos2MO
Well we simply cannot assume they are good are bad we need better security checks to see who's entering
@B324YCV3mos3MO
No, but if the government discover that the person may be a potential terrorist then thr government can take action
In this case only women and children and disabled people who have been vetted should be allowed to seek asylum
@B2R487D3mos3MO
Well, I think so. Maybe not because this is very inhumane to people in war. Just be careful who is coming in but don’t be mean to them. I’m NOT right wing.
@B2QZC6W3mos3MO
As long as the immigrant themself had no criminal tries and has a clean police record, then there should be no issue with them immigrating to Ireland.
@B2B45W84mos4MO
I do not think a ban is needed, but immigrants should be checked for any criminal history from the past.
@9ZTP7266mos6MO
As an Irish person if you want to move to Canada, Australia, America and so on you receive background checks, where possible I do believe the government should be doing more.
@9ZTM9BR6mos6MO
i don’t think they should be banned but i do think a screening should be conducted it just needs to be dealt with quickly
@9ZTFTGG6mos6MO
This should not be a question on this survey. The government should already have a procedure for screening out potential terrorists
@9ZTCYCM6mos6MO
A more vigorous screening process at customs should be introduced. The amount of healthy young men vs. Women and children entering the country needs to be addressed.
@9ZTC5VK6mos6MO
Not banned but should be a process, allow them in if high risk but not allowed to join day to day society until investigation process is done
@9ZTBVKJ6mos6MO
To assume foreign people from at risk states are terrorist risks is extremely xenophobic. There can be Irish born terrorists.
@9ZTBKMF6mos6MO
There does need to be proper screening but some people are in immediate danger in the country of origin so they should have the opportunity to still come but with restrictions and prescreening.
@9ZT666W6mos6MO
They should be allowed enter the country which is their human rigit, the screening process should happen quickly
@9ZT5NWL6mos6MO
They should be ran true a system and see how much of a danger they could be in the ares they live in and keep people safe and background checks and keep the place safe
@9ZT5DR76mos6MO
I don't think immigrants should be banned but I do think there should be a process and a background check done, especially on males who have been charged with violence against women as I do think this issue is getting a lot worse in Ireland
@9ZT5D8X6mos6MO
No I think it's inappropriate for refugees and asylum seekers to be Garda vetted before being given a safe place although it has it's risks our own people had to migrate years ago and now there are Irish families in every corner of the world now because we were welcomed and it's only fair to repay that now 800 years later
@9ZT4WQR6mos6MO
They should be vetted before granted entry, but we can’t discriminate just because of the country they’re fleeing? They’re fleeing for a reason
@9ZT39C56mos6MO
No they shouldn't be banned until there are improvements security but we should have a screening process
@9ZSZVQG6mos6MO
All immigrants should be screened before entireing country, this way nobody can complain about dangerous immigrants and they can still be let in.
@9ZRZZFN6mos6MO
I don’t think they should be banned but definitely screened for criminal records and judged on accordingly
I believe the government should house everyone in the country including immigrants and then begin bringing more immigrants in when we have the capacity
@9ZRXCZ86mos6MO
They should be screened before coming in, no convicted criminals should be allowed into this country and be housed and fed from our taxes. House our own residents first and refugees and asylum seekers in need of safety and security
@9ZRWXDX6mos6MO
Background checks for violent or sexual offenders are needed but help for the people in high risk countries mustn’t be ignored
@9ZRRMKP6mos6MO
I think they should have a agency that deals with foreign people coming into the country fleeing from war
@9ZRN4MF6mos6MO
it needs to improve FAST, i agree with allowing refugees into our country, but there needs to be a really quick- screening process to provide security to our society
@9ZRHS9YSocial Democrats6mos6MO
Screening should be a priority, but it is not fair to assume. Some Irish people are just as bad as foreign terrorists
@9ZRHGZ96mos6MO
Not completely ban but for the higher risk countries, have more regulations in place to get into the country
@9ZRDZGM6mos6MO
The screening process for immigrants needs to be improved significantly. People should not be banned from entering the country simply based off the country they’re coming from
@9ZQLH376mos6MO
The government is at fault in that it should have better screening, its not the fault of the refugees who are in danger
@9ZQ8JKH6mos6MO
no they need shelter provide houses especially for them on their own money while you check for terriorism
@9ZQ7RNG6mos6MO
It is great that the government wants to help people from high risk countries, but there is not enough houses to take them all in. The government should sort out the housing issue for people who live in this country first before taking in refugees.
@9ZQ3YHN6mos6MO
Partially. They should be kept secluded in safety until screening can be done then allow them to join the mass population
@9ZP6L786mos6MO
No, high risk countries force means immigration is more prevalent. Gov should have better means to screen high risk individuals.
@9ZP5R8R6mos6MO
Until we have the facilities to provide they should be banned as currently people are fleeing war to live in tents
I don’t think terrorism is a massive concern for Ireland however Ireland needs not currently able to facilitate high levels of immigration
@9ZLRHTR6mos6MO
This makes no sense and goes against the law of a person claiming international protection. Security checks should be more efficient and done at the first instance of claim
@9ZLNTQTSocial Democrats6mos6MO
You cannot judge someone based on where they are from. Every person entering the country should be screened.
Asylum seekers should be allowed enter the country but the government needs to improve the vetting system
@9ZLF34TSocial Democrats6mos6MO
No, but significant improvements need to be made to ensure that terrorists or convicted criminals are not easily entering the country
Immigrants from high risk countries should not be allowed enter until the government can screen who is going to be a reliable that benefits the country.
@9ZJ6XD86mos6MO
No, it’s the governments responsibility as a member of the EU to make sure we have an efficient system in place to screen out potential terrorists. We also have a legal responsibility to take in immigrants. We should prioritise women and children. That could help prevent terrorists from entering the country
@9ZHLYBKIndependent6mos6MO
High risk immigrant should be held until it is made clear that they are safe to stay otherwise return to their home country
Yes, everyone entering the country should have a full back ground check, failure to provide information, the person should be removed
@9ZHC5BSSocial Democrats6mos6MO
No, the determination of high risk is too subjective. But any individual who is or was part of a foreign military should be screened and placed under restricted licence to stay
@9ZHB4BFSocial Democrats6mos6MO
the government should screen migrants from high risk countries more carefully but no outright ban is required.
@9ZH7NQL6mos6MO
This would be a very problematic practice as it would open the floodgates to potentially use this legislation to block immigrants who are of no threat under the guise of being a potential terrorist.
@9ZH53QQ6mos6MO
I don’t believe they should be banned but each individual should be checked before allowed to enter the country
@9ZH3W6FSocial Democrats6mos6MO
No, if someone is from a dangerous country it is likely they were in danger there themselves and require asylum. However, these individuals should receive background checks
@9ZGSPPY6mos6MO
Everyone that comes into our country from a bad environment or not SHOULD BE BACKGROUND CHECKED we do not need anymore criminals or harm in this country.
@9ZGM8RX6mos6MO
We need a pause on mass immigration however those at risk should still be screened and monitored for a period of time before being granted the benefits of coming to Ireland
the process to get in should be way stricter but an outright ban is not ok - raises too many issues of racism
@9ZGJ7LR6mos6MO
No, but anyone without a valid passport should not be allowed into the country and a background check should be conducted where relevant
@9ZCJSMCSocial Democrats6mos6MO
The EU should support this and provide very high risk countries a holding area that does not last longer than 2 years
@9ZCJ225 6mos6MO
They shouldn’t be not allowed but they should be screened for past criminal offences
@9ZCGBTM6mos6MO
Better screening should be in place and nobody should be let in until they’re screened
@9ZC4QPP6mos6MO
The government should continue to improve its ability to screen out potential terrorists, however this should not impact on innocent people seeking refuge.
@9ZBVG4D6mos6MO
No, but the government should implement more thorough background checks immediately
@9ZBRPHY6mos6MO
Shouldn’t be totally banned but a better screening process is needed
@9ZBPSDL6mos6MO
People flee high risk countries to be protected but there definitely needs to be a strict screening process to prevent potential harm
@9ZBPZTW6mos6MO
Not banned but create waiting lists to allow screenings and have more strict paperwork
@9ZBJYJ26mos6MO
I think background checks should be done more thoroughly but they should be allowed into the country regardless, they need somewhere to go
@9ZBGH42Social Democrats6mos6MO
No many of those immigrants are escaping the wars most likely going on
@9Z9Z3C9 6mos6MO
Not necessarily banned, but we should definitely increase vetting process
@9Z9CFK4Independent6mos6MO
Immigration should always be done legally, barring someone from immigrating because they're from a particular country is inherently discriminative.
@9Z997FSSocial Democrats6mos6MO
No, but a thorough screening should be done with whatever tools we have available.
@9YN3S7F6mos6MO
No a person should not be discriminated against because of their nationality. However the government should improve it's screening process.
@9YLWFQB6mos6MO
No but intensive background checks are a must and no one with a criminal background should be allowed in the country
@9YLTVNS6mos6MO
Allow women and children to enter but ban men from entering until better screening is in place
@9YLPZ6B6mos6MO
no but if people from High risk countries arrive and cause disturbances and violence they should be deported
@9YKK92K6mos6MO
Yes, not necessarily banned but the government do need to improve it's screening of immigrants
They should work towards improving there strategies to screen terrorists and economic migrants without banning vulnerable genuine refugees
@9ZWG78V5mos5MO
No, immigrants should be held somewhere safe until they are screened and then either allowed stay or sent back to their home country.
@9ZWFMTL 5mos5MO
Implement more screening centres and places for immigrants to be vetted. Genuine refugees shouldn’t be denied asylum
@9ZWFB365mos5MO
Only as far as criminal records are concerned. And some sort of check to any articles, or social media presence of theirs since a lot of high risk countries lie about their terrorists so may not have a reliable record on them
@9ZW99HD5mos5MO
This question is phrased incorrectly. Should the government screen immigrants from high risk countries & all other countries. Yes
@9ZW4CM65mos5MO
Yes however they should increase the amount of efforts into researching the dangers of certain individuals .
@9ZVZVVB5mos5MO
i'm split on this everyone deserves a safe place to call home but the safety of it's citizens should be a governments first priority
@9ZVYV9F5mos5MO
No but better control measures should be put in place to ensure they are coming for legitimate purposes
@9ZVVX5F5mos5MO
No, but background checks on individuals coming from high risk countries should be mandatory and thorough.
@9ZVP4GF5mos5MO
I think it is a much more complex issue then just answering yes or no but I do think their should be stricter checks on who is entering the country as well as how they add to the economy once they arrive
@9ZVLXBK5mos5MO
They shouldn't be ban from entering but the should be heavily monitored/quarantined until they are screened
@9ZVHY7F5mos5MO
This is not about potential terrorism, but about the existing housing stock in Ireland and how we can realistically house immigrants. If we can’t house them, it is unfair to bring them in.
@9ZVH8JY5mos5MO
Corroborate intelligence on potentially threatening individuals with countries with a greater knowledge of such things and deny these malactors entrance to the country
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.