Should there be fewer or more restrictions on current social welfare benefits?
In 2011 the level of public spending on the welfare state by the British Government accounted for £113.1 billion, or 16% of government. By 2020 welfare spending will rise to 1/3rd of all spending making it the largest expense followed by housing benefit, council tax benefit, benefits to the unemployed, and benefits to people with low incomes.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province:
Region:
County:
Barony:
@9NPQ5W6 6mos6MO
More, ensuring that the benefits are going to the people that actually require it, e.g an actual jobseeker, not someone refusing to look for a job
@9ZHLYBKIndependent2wks2W
More, anyone claiming a benefit is required to join a scheme, for tidy towns, volunteering at hospital or courses for carers etc. Benefits are capped at 3 years over a lifetime.
@9ZH95KB2wks2W
I think I'd like to see both. I know that there are people that abuse the system, which is unfair to the people who genuinely need it, and I know people who the system has failed.
@9ZGMSBC2wks2W
More, People who haven't worked in a certain time period even though they are able to do so should not be allowed to receive social welfare
@9ZCWX9L2wks2W
There should be way more restrictions. Everyone who is able to work should be working. The poverty cycle will never end with the current generous welfare benefits. It is unfair to financially cripple people who are contributing to society by working and paying taxes in order to reward people who are able to work but choose not to
@9ZBHTFY2wks2W
I believe the current system works relatively well to my understanding, which is not the best in all honesty.
However, it is too easy to create and find loopholes in the current system when searching for them.
In contrast the restrictions are unintentionally targeted to reject benefits for carers.
If a carer is not working as they are required to care for their child full-time, then they are not able to get their stamps which are needed for social benefits. If the child passes away, then the carer is left unfit for work due to strain after caring for years, and also without social benefit..
@9Z9B9Y42wks2W
More restrictions and if a person can’t find a job or ANY kind within one year the social welfare benefits decrease and every 4 months after till it’s only €100 a week and if they get a job they have to be working a minimum of 1 year their before they’re entitled to benefits again - don’t allow them to get comfortable just enough to where they wanna keep their job and not doss
@9YLN4KX3wks3W
People who apply for social welfare benefits should be closer inspected to determine if they are eligible, also limits should be implemented depending on the individuals reason for needing benefits
@9ZM33B31wk1W
More, make it a living wage, but provide it to everyone regardless of employment status. Universal basic income
@9ZKSZGFPBB Solidarity2wks2W
All social welfare basic payments should be replaced by a Universal Basic Income with no strings attached, no Means Test, and freedom to supplement it with work / investments
More restrictions for Irish citizens who have never contributed to the tax system. Complete cut to welfare for newly arrived immigrants who have never paid taxes, in such cases welfare should not be paid unless in exchange for volunatry/ community work.
@9DP34DL1yr1Y
More, the current system of often exploited by people who could work but choose not to. Taking taxpayer and government money away from the people who need ot
@9MHWH2M6mos6MO
Fewer restrictions, but reform the system so that it supports more workers/taxpayers than unemployed
@9MBLRCN7mos7MO
No, hey should increase for more people in some sectors like childcare and health. Supervision should increase so the benefits go to people that really need them.
A fair society should promote job security and employment. For instance I have post-graduation and advanced degrees with international work experience but I am currently on Jobseeker’s Allowance simply because I’ve a Middle Eastern sounding Muslim name. I’ve no problem finding employment outside of Europe but anywhere in Ireland or the EU, it’s an obstacle. Plus I am also LGBTQ and I can confidently say there’s a huge gap between native Irish LGBTQ and non ethics locals. I remain closeted for the betterment of my mental healthy and sanity
@9NWX4CX6mos6MO
More restrictions, but not for the elderly, disabled or carers. Stop all asylum seekers or immigrants from abusing the systemkkk
@9MXGN7N6mos6MO
Reform the system especially when it comes to single mothers, the current system promotes them not working to be eligible for other benefits and they should be able to get benefits as required while also encouraging them to Irish their own ambitions for their self worth and mental wellbeing and perpetuations the vicious cycle of social welfare housing and unemployment and single and young parents
@937SW933yrs3Y
Those receiving it who are able should engage in community work
@9342NP93yrs3Y
Fewer, but adult recipients must be full time students, then in the workforce, and those not in full time programs must work. Benefits should not be supplied to individuals who do nothing all day but wander and congregate.
@9342NP93yrs3Y
More, but adult recipients must be full time students, then in the workforce, and those not in full time programs must work. Benefits should not be supplied to individuals who do nothing all day but wander and congregate.
@92Z5TQSIndependent3yrs3Y
Move to a more universal welfare system
@92Q58WW3yrs3Y
Due to the cost of living crisis, a review of all benefit payments should be immediately undertaken
@8TN5K923yrs3Y
More, but only for non-citizens
@8T75KXJ3yrs3Y
It should be means tested, less for people screwing the system more for people who genuinely can’t work or are in low paid work and need that help.
@8RLNYM84yrs4Y
Fewer, and technically there should not be anyone that doesn't have the possibility of living decently (housing, clothes, food, socialise, etc).
@8R6FQGW4yrs4Y
More, but increase benefits for the elderly and disabled
More, reform the system so that it supplements, rather than replaces, a working income
Fewer, current benefits do not provide enough support
Fewer, and ensure benefits go to those that need it most
@8D6GCCY4yrs4Y
Just make sure people cannot cheese the system
@8C5RDBV4yrs4Y
More, and deny benefits to immigrants.
@98R7BS42yrs2Y
End welfare and conditions, introduce a UBI.
@983X5HPFianna Fáil2yrs2Y
Fewer, those who are capable to work but do not look for employment should be cut off.
@97Y5X2Y2yrs2Y
More, reduce or remove benefits from the parents/guardians of minors who are repeat criminal offenders, and from claimants who are repeat criminal offenders
@97PZ24H2yrs2Y
I think people on long term illness benefit should be increased, these people have paid their taxes. And they should be entitled to the Christmas bonus and extra payments. Considering there’re the people who have actually contributed to the economy and when they’re recovered will contribute again.
I think it’s a big oversight.
@8NYN8NH4yrs4Y
We need a progressive system & a change in attitude. Too many people take advantage of the system. Many who try make something of themselves then don’t get the supports they need when the time comes. We need a more Sweden-like societal approach.
@942X28Z2yrs2Y
Social welfare should be abandoned for a negative income
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
@ISIDEWITH2mos2MO
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.