Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Province:
County:
Barony:
Electoral Division:
Civil Parish:
Townland:
@9DY8GQC1yr1Y
They should be able to sit in the Dáil and have a small input when topics that effect the north are being discussed
@8QY2T3L4yrs4Y
Yes, but no voting rights.
@9NN4VF76mos6MO
Without the context of how it would impact dail operations or constituents either side of the border, this is a difficult question to answer. If it's with a view to a united Ireland, then absolutely yes.
@9ZBWXFP4wks4W
It depends of said elected parliament seats can benefit to the Republic of Ireland and vice versa for the Republic of Ireland with Northern Ireland
No, but a cross border committee should be established invoking representatives from both parliaments
@9ZBKNT54wks4W
I believe members of the northern parliament should be allowed confer and discuss polices with members of the dáil
no, but there should be a regular forum of discussion between both parliaments to ensure continued cooperation and peace between the two states
@9ZB9WB94wks4W
governmentally they arent a part of the same country, however if the county were to choose to relinquish a position in the united kingdom government then i dont see whu not
@9Z997FSSocial Democrats4wks4W
Yes, but only participating in sessions in the Dáil that affect Northern Ireland as well as the Republic
@9YN3S7F4wks4W
If the topic has an effect on the island of Ireland as a whole, yes. But not a permanent seat unless we are reunified.
@9YN59YS4wks4W
If it will benefit a United Ireland and peoples livelihood. Not to add ‘British perspective’ to Irish politics
@9YLKJLJ4wks4W
If an agreement with NI and Ireland was created that we could have some irish politicians over in that Parliament
Yes, especially if the question of unification is to be brought up, This will endure all parties have the same information and get their points across in the same forum
@9ZD68GG3wks3W
They should be allowed sit in with no input unless they are asked or if the matter is regarding both north and south
@9ZBZHGQ4wks4W
only for all island policies or possibly boarder communities. but not for policy that won’t affect the north
@9ZCST6F3wks3W
Sure but only when topics concerning both sides of the border are discussed and the republics TD’s have the same opportunity
I would like to say yes, but would that not mean they are actually there under the British government and not Irish… So my answer is no.
@9F7N5W71yr1Y
Only people that swear an oath to the republic
@9F49VTM1yr1Y
Only when desison are being made which effects both parties
@9DYLQGN1yr1Y
In some circumstances but only on the rare occasion.
@9ZHLD2NSocial Democrats3wks3W
Yes if they are from nationalist, all-island parties and the discussions to do with cross-border issues
@9N8KHQ56mos6MO
No feel that it would be only those elected in Ireland. They can may give views but not voting as currently they are a separate nation
If the discussion or work is involving a cross boarder issue or discussion of unity they should be able to do a working visit.
@9MKQ2XD7mos7MO
Yes but only when all parties in the north work for all the people and work together for the good of all the people.
@9LRVPFWIndependent Left7mos7MO
No, but there should be an all-island body containing elected members from both sides that consults on issues that might affect the entire island.
@9JYYK2B10mos10MO
Yes to a degree, it is important to take their opinion into consideration on certain issues, particualrly those that will have implications for the North.
If they are from nationalist parties not unionist
Only if Ireland is reunited
@99NRNLN2yrs2Y
I don’t know enough about this
@9ZJQMRM3wks3W
Yes, if they are in favour of unified Ireland: they represent the voices of potential future fellow countrymen
@9NMJGTZ6mos6MO
Yes, members of the Northern Irish Assembly at Stormont should be able to represent the same constituencies in the Dáil
@9NPQ5W6 6mos6MO
In aid of unity yes. In the present circumstances of Northern Ireland and the republic being separate, no
No but members of both parliaments should meet regularly to discuss and co-operate on island wide affairs
@8G8G3D64yrs4Y
Yes they should when we talk about investing in Northern Ireland the Immergration & the Irish language & Covid19 & Brexit
@96QHBLJ2yrs2Y
It would probably cause a sovereignty conflict with Great Britain so no, they should not.
@96PQ2PF2yrs2Y
No unionists but nationalists Ok
@96NK9692yrs2Y
Yes, but only those from border counties.
@96FM8WF2yrs2Y
Northern Ireland should be incorporated into Ireland
@96BG3N32yrs2Y
Constituencies in the North of Ireland should be allowed to elect TDs to the Dáil. Stormont MLAs and Westminster MPs should not sit in the Dáil.
@9624BKJSocial Democrats2yrs2Y
Once a united Ireland is achieved
@95YYYN72yrs2Y
Yes, but should be non voting
@95TTDNZ2yrs2Y
Not until there is there is a btmetter relationship between North and south
Yes, they have the right to sit in Westminster and Stormont,why not the dail as well
@946QGCN2yrs2Y
A repersentive body of Northern Irish Mps should sit in on relevant meetings/boards.
@93ZRGNQ2yrs2Y
Yes, but they should not be allowed to vote on bills.
@92Z5TQSIndependent3yrs3Y
Yes, As long as they swear allegiance to the irish republic
@92THRWV3yrs3Y
Only of they consider themselves irish
@92RG4SLIndependent3yrs3Y
Perhaps for some sittings that are relevant but not all
@92NBW3C3yrs3Y
They should have speaking rights, but not voting rights
@92FCTRC3yrs3Y
They should be able to attend as observers, and contribute to debates, but not have a vote.
As long as they are relevant and non extremist
@8ZVQCLCFianna Fáil3yrs3Y
Yes, but only when addressing issues that affect the entire island of Ireland
@8ZML6RY3yrs3Y
Only if the become part of the independent Republic
Depends on their views of the republic
@8ZCXFYRFianna Fáil3yrs3Y
Yes if it involves Northern Ireland and that Irish tds be allowed sit in stormonth
@8ZBJCZFFianna Fáil3yrs3Y
Yes, but I don't see how Unionist politicians such as those in the DUP would want to do this
Yes but only nationalist parties and no unionist parties
@8YYTV56Social Democrats3yrs3Y
Yes but it there becomes a united ireland or an agreement to rule ireland as a whole instead of the possibility of conflict between laws
@8YTXZTSSocial Democrats3yrs3Y
If their political leadership works together
Depends on the topics being discussed
@8YLXLQPSocial Democrats3yrs3Y
Yes their as important as Lisa Chambers Eammon Ryan & Mary Lou Mcdonald
@8YLVTJRIndependent3yrs3Y
Not in the current climate
@8XSVGX7Social Democrats3yrs3Y
Yes, but only if referendums held on both Northern Ireland and the Republic agree
@8WZP7FC3yrs3Y
Yes, but only for debates regarding Northern Ireland.
@8WZMPDB3yrs3Y
Yes but not to vote, until unity
@8TQCVTC3yrs3Y
No, but people in Northern Ireland should be able to elect TDs directly to the Dáil.
@8TPHYZK3yrs3Y
Yes but not have the same rights
@8TN6DGP3yrs3Y
Only if Ireland reunifies
Yes, but only with speaking rights.
@8TC577X3yrs3Y
Sit, yes if they wish. Discuss decisions made by the Irish government which may impact the north. They should not have a vote or push through laws which are not applicable to them in the dail though.
@8QLJCRT3yrs3Y
Aontaím, mar tá sé tabachtach go mbíonn glór ag gach duine Éireannach faoi fud an hOileán na hÉireann i nDáil - Yes, because it's important that every Irish person throughout the island of Ireland has a voice in the Dáil
@8SW95FT4yrs4Y
Only in a United Ireland
@8SQMNL84yrs4Y
Yes, only after a peblicite in both nations and only if northern Ireland was an independent nation
@8SP6GX44yrs4Y
Only in the event of a United Ireland
@8SBVYYK4yrs4Y
No but they should liase with the Dáil
@8S27VRW4yrs4Y
yes but they should only have speaking rights.
@8RX7F7G4yrs4Y
An All-Ireland council should be set up for coordinating between Stormont and the Dail
@8RQ5ZYP4yrs4Y
On occasion their input could be valuable. We do live on the same island.
@8RM3RDP4yrs4Y
Only in a United Ireland.
@8RLNYM84yrs4Y
Yes if questions are regarding the people they represent
@8RGQX6C4yrs4Y
Yes, but not to vote in the Dáil (spectator)
@8RGQX6C4yrs4Y
Yes, but not to vote in the Dáil
@8QY7HG84yrs4Y
No, but should be represented in Seanad Éireann.
@8Q7DC734yrs4Y
Only Republicans, No Unionists
@8Q5TQ3N4yrs4Y
Yes on issues that relate to both countries
@8PMXMKK4yrs4Y
If the issue relates to both parts of the island
@8PFH4YX4yrs4Y
I think when Ireland and The United Kingdom establish a better Brexit agreement then maybe
Yes but Only if an issue being discussed is relevant to both North and South.
@8P6Y59C4yrs4Y
On Border Issues yes otherwise, no
@8NQM5PR4yrs4Y
If the country was united
@8NNN5ZC4yrs4Y
until reunification otherwise they'll have to be happy with the cross border agencies they have at the moment
@8JMRLFS4yrs4Y
Maybe but I wouldn’t think so
yes and no, they are part of the British parliament, not the Irish parliament but due to the circumstances of Brexit they should be allowed in the dail so that a Brexit deal can be done
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.