Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province:
County:
Region:
Barony:
I think there should be an EU intelligence agency but without having to merge other intelligence agency’s together
@8ZVQCLCFianna Fáil3yrs3Y
No, but intelligence agencies should closely work together when solving international crimes
No, although I do think there should be a central EU intelligence agency, member states should be entitled to maintain their own intelligence organisations.
@9K5NFWL11mos11MO
We should have a central EU intelligence agency but not necessarily made up from all the individual countries' intelligence agency.
@9M7MR9Y9mos9MO
A central EU agency should be established, but national intelligence agencies should still exist separately.
intelligence agencies should be abolished
@9YMPS6B2mos2MO
Each country should have their own intelligence agency, however all EU countries should be closely linked
@9NWX4CX7mos7MO
I believe they should have members from all IAs come together as an agency outside individual agencies but only as a means to associate and discuss choices and outcomes.
@9SWMJY6Independent5mos5MO
The E.U. is not a nation and nation states should maintain their sovereignty and security, cooperation between EU countries in regards to policing i.e. Interpol is sufficient. The sharing of information should be freely offered but not to the detriment of ongoing investigations or potential military breaches
@9BSTGM82yrs2Y
@99MD7PFSocial Democrats2yrs2Y
Cooperate and a central agency but not merge or replace national
@998K78Q2yrs2Y
No, co operate with other intelligence agencies on a case by case basis.
@93FJZV73yrs3Y
Yes, but not fully merged and as an umbrella/bridge.
@8TPJ9733yrs3Y
No, but I do believe in a oversight body and a higher level of cooperation
@8TPHYZK3yrs3Y
No not merged, states need separate intelligence agencies, but these intelligence services must be able to connect to protect the EU, especially since there is the freedom of travel and as terrorists can move between borders
@8RLZCHW4yrs4Y
Yes, but each country should still have their own specific agencies
@8RJXJG44yrs4Y
Ireland should set up its own Agency
@8PYZ4BK4yrs4Y
No but there should be greater co-operation between intelligence agencies.
@8KP7HSQIndependent4yrs4Y
There should be a central EU one for training and cooperation, however, individual nation states should be able to retain their own.
@8J2LNT24yrs4Y
That should be reviewed & debated
@8H4GD784yrs4Y
that needs to be debated & looked at
No, but cooperation should be enouraged
@9BHDHBB2yrs2Y
Not Merged, but better Intergated
Yes there should be a main one but every country should have its own small one too
@99QPD4Q2yrs2Y
No but there should be some form if cooperation
@983X5HPFianna Fáil2yrs2Y
No, but cooperation between EU countries, and worldwide, with Europol/Interpol should increase
@97Q84D42yrs2Y
We would review that policy we do have over our intelligence agencies it may will need to be updated
@92NBW3C3yrs3Y
I would keep individual agencies but improve cooperation between them
@8ZP8PFFSocial Democrats3yrs3Y
Yes, it will make the EU more unified and efficient.
@8YYYXXKIndependent3yrs3Y
No. Interpol already exists. The EU can set certain standards that individual states must adhere to, and do audits to ensure these standards are being met, but for an individual nations national security, they should withhold their information from other states unless agreements between individual states exist.
@8YLXLQPSocial Democrats3yrs3Y
In theory yes but right now its not an because the rule of Law in countries outside EU
@8Y9Z24T3yrs3Y
No, however intelligence should be shared so long as it has been legally obtained and is subject to legal oversight
No, complete centralization would put the EU as a whole at greater risk of infiltration, sabotage, etc, especially by Israel.
@8XFLST73yrs3Y
intelligence agencies should be merged to create a central EU agency not before they agree to give up their Independent status
@8WHXYLT3yrs3Y
A joint taskforce could be useful, but not to merge altogether
@8VZMSGX3yrs3Y
It should be dual. A national system that can work in conjucntion with a european system when required
@8TM8WLZ3yrs3Y
Yes, but only for countries which haven't had significant intelligence leaked to non-EU countries (e.g. Russia)
@8S27VRW4yrs4Y
yes when dealing with external affairs
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.