Should it be illegal to burn the Irish flag?
Flag desecration is any act that is carried out with the intention of damaging or destroying a national flag in public. This is commonly done in an effort to make a political statement against a nation or its policies. Some nations have acts that ban flag desecration while others have laws that protect the right to destroy a flag as a part of free speech. Some of these laws distinguish between a national flag and those of other countries.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Province:
County:
Region:
Barony:
Electoral Division:
@9ZLLNKR2mos2MO
No, it's just a piece for cloth. Person who feels the need to burn it has bigger issues and we have better use of our legal resources.
@9FKKNMQ1yr1Y
yes but and add an extra year to the sentence if there not irish
@8VZK8MD3yrs3Y
@9ZTDF4K2mos2MO
No, it is the proper the respectful way to dispose of a nations flag as long as its done respectfully
@9ZMGKRGIndependent 2mos2MO
It should be considered the same as vandalising public/private property and the consequences reflect that as an act of violence/vandalism.
@9ZL76C2Independent2mos2MO
Why would this be a question, the only people who would burn the Irish flag is the woke fools in this country
@9ZJL48VPBB Solidarity2mos2MO
If a flag burning incited violence against the people from that country, no. Otherwise yes but I don't think it is ethical
@9ZJQ8WZPeople Before Profit2mos2MO
Personally I think it should be illegal but I also acknowledge other people's opinions and the right to free speech
@9Z979SP3mos3MO
I would rather 9 bad actors and 1 legitimate actor be able to burn the flag rather than 10 actors being legally unable to
@9ZF9GNZ3mos3MO
Burning my flag does not destroy the idealism and symbol it has become. Preferably we’d still have the green flag and the harp as per the IRB.
@9ZDP53Q3mos3MO
I would never do it and I don't think someone should face charges for it but doing it is incredibly disrespectful to the country and the people and for what they stand for
@9Z9F7P43mos3MO
I think it shouldn't be ILLEGAL, however people who do such things should be looked into, e.g. are they threatening violent acts on others. I don't think that any flag should be burned though, it is very disrespectful.
@9YN486Q3mos3MO
No, not as far as being illegal. If it’s because of being against our country then create a small fine but there’s also a fine-line between freedom of speech and straight up disrespect
@9YMB59J3mos3MO
I don’t agree with arson, however, I do not feel overly offended by damage of a flag, unless it’s a hate crime
@8QT462D4yrs4Y
Yes, and make it a criminal offence.
@92BXXWC3yrs3Y
Yes Aslong it's not where someone would be offended
@9RGDDQG6mos6MO
No, but there should be a very valid constitutional reason why they choose to as a political statement.
@97Y8SG52yrs2Y
No if in a safe context (peaceful, organised protest for example), Yes if it's hooliganism or hate speech.
@8RLNYM84yrs4Y
No, it is just a piece of cloth, nationalism should not be a thing
@9SZSJTT5mos5MO
It largely depends on context, usually I would say its fine, however if it is used as a type of poltical ramification of incompetence, then no
@9BK6M642yrs2Y
I don’t support it but it should not become illegal.
No, but the British and Irish press should not sanitize the most salient of these incidents, which happen in bonfires in loyalist strongholds in the six counties every July. These are hateful, divisive, and ugly spectacles which Irish people not only in the six counties but also in the South and in the diaspora find deeply offensive and we get impatient with coverage of this as a mere community tradition rather than the bigoted supremacist disgrace that it is.
@9FTNFTG1yr1Y
If you burnt it in your home, then no its not illegal, but if its in a public space or on someone else’s property, you should be fined and punished.
@9FLJ4BF1yr1Y
Yes, it should be illegal and should be disposed of properly but no one should go to jail for it only if it was done countless times and began to feel violent
@8ZH8YNQ3yrs3Y
We should be focused on bigger problems then the legality of burning a flag eg. climate change
@8CVTX3V4yrs4Y
It's disrespectful but it shouldn't be illegal
@9BLQXF92yrs2Y
No, but there should be a fine
@99LBZB62yrs2Y
Accompanied by a 2 year course in civics
@999D9FX2yrs2Y
only if the flag is your property.
@96QYLWQ2yrs2Y
It should be legal if the country is attacking other countries or doesn't respect human rights to education etc. Example currently Russia and Afghanistan. Otherwise should be treated as offenses if done for fun, entrainment only with no important purpose.
@9BBWHKXIndependent2yrs2Y
I don't believe it should be criminalised but I do not condone this sort of action.
@96ZGXPLIndependent2yrs2Y
Not necessarily illegal but there should be a fine or consequence
@96K8N862yrs2Y
Yes, but only if it is done out of racism towards Ireland
@96CRDX5Social Democrats2yrs2Y
If any country do anything bed(e.g. war) people can do it
@964N42J2yrs2Y
Yes and The Person shall be punished severly
@8YDXWRV3yrs3Y
Should be illegal but brining the flag means they don’t like the county so deport them
The flag should be fireproof.
@98PTPF62yrs2Y
No, unless it is used to incite a crowd to riot
Only in a sectarian context
@97YN924Fianna Fáil2yrs2Y
Make it legal to do so but only the Irish flag no other nations
@8RP2FN44yrs4Y
If they so chose to then they shouldn't be living in Ireland if they hate it that much
@8QZTLBY4yrs4Y
No bc if they do I will fart on them
@8QKZZMR4yrs4Y
I don't support the UK anyways.
@8DJ7DHH4yrs4Y
as long as they are not trying to incite violence then it is not a crime, but I don't agree with burning of the Irish flag.
@8DGPWCB4yrs4Y
Yes but no, it violates free speech but it also is frowned apon
Not a fan of burning the Irish flag, but citizens should get tax credits for burning the Israeli flag publicly.
@8SW6W8S4yrs4Y
Don't really have an opinion
@8RPFXDH4yrs4Y
If they so chose to then they shouldn't be living in the UK
@8DG6RF44yrs4Y
This is done in the North by Loyalists to oppress Irish people living in the North on 12th July. For this reason alone, it should be illegal to burn the flag of any nation.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@8XR8DQ23yrs3Y
No, unless its in public and could cause greater risk if the fire spreads.
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.