Should Ireland raise taxes on the rich?
Australia currently has a progressive tax system whereby high income earners pay a higher percentage of tax than low income tax. A more progressive income tax system has been proposed as a tool towards reducing wealth inequality.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Ideology:
Province:
Region:
County:
Electoral Division:
@9ZCWBTS3mos3MO
Define ‘rich’. If it’s a middle/lower class person who is working two jobs and getting over-taxed because of this then no, if it’s a upper-class person who can survive with being taxed more then yes.
@9HD2Q4V1yr1Y
Absolutely not.I believe in a more simplified tax system and flat income tax . Income Tax 20% ,Corporate 6.5% ,VAT and sales will stay the same. Inheritance,Capital Gains,Carbon and property tax should be removed
@97TK3872yrs2Y
The government should make a clear distinction between those that are cash rich and asset rich. A farmer with hundreds and thousands of euro worth of land is asset rich but may not have cash liquidity and should not be taxed at a higher rate. However a large corporation owner who is both asset and cash rich should be taxed at a higher rate as they can afford to pay it.
More tax for businesses. Those who are holding property should be taxed more. More tax on mass rental individuals.
@9K486Y811mos11MO
Taxes should be fairly redeemed, if the earner cannot live comfortably because their money has gone on tax, the tax should be lowered, likewise if a person is a very high earner and a higher rate of tax would not effect their comfort of living then the higher tax should be paid. What I have stated is the same structure that we already have but it needs to be fine tuned to find a better balance I believe.
@97YBF9B2yrs2Y
No, but increase corporate tax
@9ZXBJ9V2mos2MO
I believe we should have a new tax system with about 5 new brackets taking a lot of pressure of the small pockets and a bit with the average pockets but a bit more pressure on deep pockets
I haven’t worked out the numbers but something like
-€20,000 10%
€20,000-€40,000 20%
€40,000-€75,000 30%
€75,000-€250,000 40%
€250,000- 50%
@9ZWLV6Y2mos2MO
The tax bracket should raise taxes for those earning a salary over 90-100K a year. People earning under this at the moment are seeing half it go to tax and left with nothing. Struggling to save for homes and desperately renting these terrible living conditions
@9ZWFB362mos2MO
We need to prevent the loopholes by corporations yes. But also, income tax needs reforming. I think higher paid people should get an increased tax, but the tax bands should change. The tax bands are way too low and take advantage of most people unfairly. If we had more tax on corporations, as well as preventing loopholes, could allow the tax bands to be much wider (and more of them) and more reasonable for most people. Such as only 20% up to more like 70-80k ( for singles I mean. That is around the number for just married couples, but that should be better still as well). Then perhaps 35% (or… Read more
progressive tax system whereby high income earners pay a higher percentage of tax than low income tax. A more progressive income tax system has been proposed as a tool towards reducing wealth inequality.
@9ZWCFSG2mos2MO
yes but lower the income tax rate for lower tax brackets and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations
depending on income and affordability, im a middle person and i feel we're left out of any changes and suffer the most.
@9ZW35MHSocial Democrats2mos2MO
I think the tax bracket should be higher, like higher than 40k and it should be taxed more when it's 100k or more
The government should not be allowed to penalise someone for warning a goof wage. The higher tax bracket makes it pointless to want to earn more if you'll be on higher tax.
@9ZVYV9F2mos2MO
Rich would need to be defined. Middle income earners should not reach the 40% tax until at least 60,000
@9ZVSP9D2mos2MO
Yes but by rich I do not mean a professional working wage. As a young professional who has good career prospects, I will have a lot of expenses, and raising my taxes will make things difficult to pay for, as I do not qualify for any means tested measures etc
@9ZVMQDW2mos2MO
We should incentivise people to do well in this country instead of taxing anyone that does, every budget is an increase for people on social welfare who may have never worked for a day in their life. I am all for helping out anyone who may be disabled in a way they cannot work but this country is far too lenient with people who choose not too work
@9ZVK2S82mos2MO
Tax should be layered based on your salary, not just a big jump from lower tax bracket to higher tax bracket
@9ZVHY7F2mos2MO
Yes, for the ‘super rich’ - people earning millions each year. And also a reduction for lower income households should be reflected in this. Often it is the middle who are squeezed, and in this cost of living crisis, even 100k salaries are not providing huge amounts of disposable income - no point increasing tax on people like those, at least they have a chance of purchasing homes.
@9ZVGBNTIndependent2mos2MO
Dont increase on rich- for people in middle and poor it should be lowered and the least government could do is abolish the usc.
More tax increments should be in place is reduce the 40% on the 4000 and up and change to 30’percent on 4000 to 7000 and then add 40-50% on 7000 and up
@9ZTL28Y2mos2MO
Raise income tax for the top income bracket and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations.
@9ZT44TZ2mos2MO
No, but the government should actually put the current taxes to proper use, i.e. healthcare, roads etc.
@9ZS6WNY2mos2MO
For multi millionaires yes but not for ordinary people who have become successful and earning 100,000-250,000 a year
@9ZRBLXT2mos2MO
I’m regards to this question I feel that we are trying to strive for equality within a society and yet trying to take it away from others at the same time so no
@9ZQPPF52mos2MO
To a degree. For people bringing in hundreds of thousands of euros a year, definitely. For those working multiple jobs to stay afloat, or for those with dependent people in the household, absolutely not.
@9ZQ7FPM2mos2MO
It depends on how you define rich. I would support higher taxes for people who earn more than 300K per year or people who have assets in excess of 5 million
@9ZPR96C2mos2MO
Tax on vacant homes and derelict buildings should be increased. Not all wealth is liquid/available. I.e Farms are land roch but can be cash poor.
@9ZH95KB3mos3MO
I would say yes, and I also agree with the point on lowering the income tax for individuals with lower income and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations.
@9ZH4C5NSocial Democrats3mos3MO
Taxes should be raised for the richer end of the income brackets and remove any tax loopholes for large corporations while reducing taxes for lower income earners and abolishing USC like it was intended.
@9ZGNCP53mos3MO
the entire tax system needs to be reformed so nobody is penalised just for earning a certain amount of money
@9ZGMSBC3mos3MO
Tax brackets should be raised. Examples: No tax up to 20,000, 20% up to 60,000 and 40% on income over that.
@9ZGJP7K3mos3MO
increase taxes for large corporations and people in the top 2% but lower tax for the people in the middle and low end
@9ZDTDJS3mos3MO
Create more tax brackets as the gap I’m the existing tax structure is too big. Everyone should contribute some income tax regardless of their income.
@9ZDJWLT3mos3MO
Low corporation tax for big companies needs to be reassessed. Taxing rich individuals will not have the same impact as taxing big corporations that make billions of euro through deals with the Irish government.
@9ZSDYQJ2mos2MO
Raise it on higher tax brackets but raise it on a higher income then the current tax bracket and put more time into preventing tax evasion by large companies
@9ZKRRRL2mos2MO
Yes, increase taxes for rich. It is much more important to remove loopholes that large cooperations use and loopholes multimillionaires and billionaires use.
@9ZCHNJL3mos3MO
Should depend on how much income you get depending on the person, each job is different and each person is different.
@9ZCFL9X3mos3MO
Adjust tax brackets to make the 40% PAYE a lower rate for those that make just slightly above the lower bracket
@9ZBGXQD3mos3MO
Ideally yes but risk assessment would have to be done as it could cause corporations to leave and leave the jobs behind, whichever is calculated to work better
@9ZBCHDP3mos3MO
I don’t think it’s fair to tax the working class and give it away as social welfare for people who are too lazy to get a job
@9ZBBNK33mos3MO
Only increase tax on the ultra wealthy as opposed to wealthy people as they already pay up to 40% income tax.
@9Z9B7YQ3mos3MO
A definition of ‘rich’ needs to be made - the top percentage of earners in Ireland on salaries of 350,000 plus should be taxed higher.
@9YNC9G43mos3MO
Yes there should be tax taken out but half of the wages should be taxed tax should be a 5% taken out and put init a saving fund for pension and to not be paying for people who come to the country and not work
@9ZM2S5Z2mos2MO
If you’re paying high tax then healthcare, education and other services have to be free. Can’t pay high tax while also having to pay all those expensive services
I think there should be a higher tax rate for individuals earning over certain amounts such as over 100k.
@9ZFKFQD3mos3MO
Asset and property tax to increase plus removing existing tax loopholes for large corporations, remove income tax for all persons, but ensure that wealth is taxed to prevent multigenerational empires
@9ZFJ7NG3mos3MO
any increase or decreases on taxes rates should increase and decrease by the same rate for the poor and rich
@98LYYXW2yrs2Y
Yes, decrease for the poor and and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations
@97YBKZG2yrs2Y
Wat does 'the rich' mean in this context. Cant answer without knowing
Only for the rich rich like 500,000 plus
@9NL8CL38mos8MO
Yes, there should be 3 tax bands. Low income, middle income and higher income. The middle income tax band should be >55,000 and a higher rate should be implemented for >120,000
@9HM7ZJW1yr1Y
Lower income tax. Corporations will alway find loopholes to avoid taxes and it will be passed down to small business and etc.
@9HG9R461yr1Y
NO, The tax system needs more brackets, with rates not exceeding 38% until earning over 80,000 a year, income up to the first 40,000 should be lowered dramatically, whether this is made from a single job or multiple, this will help poor people increase their quality of life and reward their hard work
Lower the tax for middle class as the middle class are the ones most struggling as they aren’t entitled to absolutely anything and are paying the most tax this current financial situation the country is in isn’t affecting the people on the dole or the rich as much as it is THE MIDDLE CLASS it is an absolute joke
Add a third tax bracket, taxing those with exceedingly high incomes, making a more progressive taxation policy
Increase taxes for the rich, lower taxes for the poor, and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations.
@9D4TFPR 1yr1Y
@9NYLH8H8mos8MO
Add a third rate cut off over 100k, but also increase current rate cut off points for 20% and 40%. Salaries are not increasing for working and middle class
@9GQDVHS1yr1Y
Move up the bracket that they believe is rich (people in the “rich bracket” might not even have a house of their own due to housing crisis
@9FSNKTQ1yr1Y
there should be an bracket percentage that applies to everyone so 40% above $4000 should apply to everyone
@9FQFH6Y1yr1Y
Create multi tiered tax threshold
Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes
@9DM9X3Q1yr1Y
Tax simply doesn’t exist, it’s a scam, the banks use “tax” and “interest” as there source if income (that’s what they tell us but it’s false) in actuality the banks print money of demand (192.000.000 per day)
@9DFHLTJ1yr1Y
Rich pay higher taxes, less well off pay lower taxes, decrease burden on middle earner as well
@9XRVKFM3mos3MO
Yes but make the threshold in which someone is considered “rich” higher. I don’t see a major benefit in increasing taxes on high paying jobs rather than multimillionaires
@9QC6Y9M7mos7MO
Income taxes are easily avoided, a robust Land Value Tax should be introduced. This would effectively increase the tax base, particularly to capture large land holders who are the truly wealthy in society.
@9NP826W8mos8MO
It is a question best left to those well read in economic policy and of good sense, honour and standing.
@9NLLGK48mos8MO
Raising or lowering these taxes will have very little impact in the long run, but more money should be invested in the revenue service to find and arrest tax criminals and tighten the definition on tax dodging.
@952V28J2yrs2Y
No, abolish the income tax and get rid of unneeded deductions, e.g. USC
@93XZPBT3yrs3Y
Keep existing structure but adding CGT bands and add wealth tax that includes property.
@93TSWYR3yrs3Y
Reform to a flat tax rate and remove all existing tax loopholes.
@93TSBPP3yrs3Y
Raising some taxes to pay for better public services cannot be avoided
Increase wealth tax but reduce income tax burden on middle & higher earners.
@93DK9X63yrs3Y
Yes, and increase advertisement tax, and get help from the eu to get our fair share from big corporations in Ireland.
@Ronagig3yrs3Y
Raise middle to high income Lower for the poor Eliminate loopholes
@9342NP93yrs3Y
Yes, and lower the income rate for those earning individually under 125K/year and families earning under 200K/year; Increase taxes on corporations and remove existing tax loopholes for the wealthy and corporations.
@92Z5TQSIndependent3yrs3Y
Move income tax to a flat rate, increase emphasis on assets taxes, eg Land, Water, sales etc
@92S44TK3yrs3Y
Introduce a moderate rate of income tax for median earners and increase both the band and the rate for the highest earners -
@92P7QV63yrs3Y
Yes, but in such a way as to ensure that no capital flight occurs and receipts actually go up.
@8ZYBKZK3yrs3Y
No it there money most of the time and work hard for it most of the time
@8ZPL5S23yrs3Y
Not completely but in some cases yes but we the way that the tax is used is more important
@8ZP8PFFSocial Democrats3yrs3Y
Yes. Remove all existing corporate tax loopholes and introduce progressive tax brackets for capital gains and corporate profits.
@8ZKFSXK3yrs3Y
No , asset’s should be used to increase wealth and a deal should be made with corporations so they can maximise prophets and in return serve national interests
@8NZ4BHQSocial Democrats4yrs4Y
No, but lower taxes for the poor and keep it the same for the rich
@8JMRZ3P4yrs4Y
everyone should have to pay the same amount of tax
@8NV29534yrs4Y
Focus on asset taxes and loopholes, have everyone pay something.
@98QNCZG2yrs2Y
Have better tax bands that are progressive.
@8TN6HKH4yrs4Y
Yes but the threshold values for taxation should be changed. The current threshold for upper tax is too low.
@8TC3GSR4yrs4Y
Yes, and lower taxes on low incomes
@8T7R2G54yrs4Y
Yes, and lower tax on lower income brackets.
@8T3PBNB4yrs4Y
Yes but raise tax brackets and make another higher one.
@8SRR5HT4yrs4Y
Raise taxes on politicians
@8SG6MCN4yrs4Y
Reform the tax structure, widen the base but make it more progressive. Collect Corp taxes and close down loopholes. Enforce taxation on vacant housing and land value taxation
@8RX92PT4yrs4Y
No, but a wealth tax on the very rich should be introduced
@8RQCJ294yrs4Y
The cut off point for income tax should be highered.
@8RQ5ZYP4yrs4Y
Yes, though not to astronomically high levels
@8RP579T4yrs4Y
Yes, but only by a tiny percentage. Taxes should also be raised on the middle class.
@8RLNYM84yrs4Y
Raise the income tax for rich people and remove all existing tax loopholes for large corporations
@8R5CFQJ4yrs4Y
More tax on the biggest corporations
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.