Should the government provide social welfare benefits to foreigners?
Irish welfare benefits for intra-EU migrants are amongst the highest in the EU in the areas of job seekers allowance, healthcare, old-age pensions, and child benefit. The Irish Examiner recently reported that more than a 20% of unemployment benefits recipients in Ireland are from other EU countries. In Germany, for example, 2.5% of unemployment benefit recipients are from other EU countries.
Yes, as long as they are working and paying taxes Or are refugees or asylum seekers.
@9LP35DQ4 days4D
Yes for asylum seekers and refugees, as well as those working and paying taxes. Not those arriving without work not fleeing war etc.
@9L5KJHW4wks4W
Yes for those who are citizens of the country with jobs but still have trouble meeting the cost of living. Also yes for refugees and asylum seekers if it is within the countries means to do so.
@9KC2MMCSocial Democrats2mos2MO
For refugees and asylum seekers as long as they are working and paying taxes, or are in the process of finding work.
@9K7RC952mos2MO
Yes, but the amount of benefits received would begin to reduce rapidly after the first month and provide them with jobs instead
@9K486Y82mos2MO
If I was a foreign national going to a country that gives money for nothing I would absolutely be taking advantage of that. It is human nature and nothing will change that. We have our own problems with our own people, homelessness being caused by many reasons and normal working class families losing their homes yet we will provide foreign nationals aid before our own people. There is no excuse for poverty and homelessness to our own people, and using a cop out excuse luke drug addictions or people of an savoury nature is not excceptable as this is the monster that the government has created through neglect. Charity begins at home.
Once there is clear effort being made to find a job, and not taking advantage of the system like some do, including Irish
I beleive if we have a good social housing system with no competition or vulture funds , we can take in refugees , I think we should be focusing on countries such as east Asia, Africa and Middle East , places who are not in Europe as most European countries take in the same people so as a country who fought occupation we should help those facing occupation and imperialism although we have to accommodate our own first
@9HSTJMDRepublican Sinn Féin4mos4MO
Not for unemployment benefits, but yes for other benekfts if they are working and contributing to the economy, and assimilated into our culture
@9HQ3JGZ4mos4MO
Yes but they have to embrace our language and culture and only too people who’s countries are in a terrible state
@9HGMVLNFianna Fáil5mos5MO
Yes the government should. However, any immigrants coming into the country should be on a lower social welfare than they are currently
@9GPNZ4W6mos6MO
Yes, but time limited. After 3-6 months they should either be in a position to support themselves (economic migrants) or show that it would be unsafe to return home (refugees)
Yes but only if they are working and paying taxes but after 5 years migrants should stop getting welfare
@9F333H3Social Democrats8mos8MO
After an appropriate period of time
@9DQHHGMRenua Ireland8mos8MO
Yes, but very strict to be allowed, as long as they have resided for 2 year’s minimum with full time employment and it should only be allowed for a maximum of 6 months.
Yes if their financial situation warrants it
Only for EU and UK citizens, or where third country nationals have already paid tases.
@92RB3D32yrs2Y
Yes, If they are Expats, working & paying taxes and also to those who cannot work yet such as refugees and asylum seekers
@92NBW3C2yrs2Y
Yes, after being in the country for 5 + years legally
No social welfare should be abolished
@9C8ZS92Social Democrats11mos11MO
Yes for refugees, asylum seekers and for those working and paying taxes here.
@9C7YQCK11mos11MO
Yes, but only for EU or CTA citizens
@9BWPXSV12mos12MO
Yes, but only after the Irish people who need it are taken care of first
@9BPH73L12mos12MO
No, but it should be made easier to apply for citizenship.
@9BJNKFB1yr1Y
If screened to be safe, have intention to work and participated in assimilation classes on language, ethics, culture, law of the land and exhibited respect and effort to work or if previously had a long term job and lost it due to unexpected circumstances beyond their control
@9BJFGH71yr1Y
yes if they are working or paying taxes or if they are refugees and asylum seekers or unable to work for medical reasons
@9BDJ45YIndependent1yr1Y
if they help are people first
@9BBWHKXIndependent1yr1Y
I support this if they are permanent residents who are working and paying taxes
Yes, if they are legally Irish citizens
@99V72GY1yr1Y
Tax and reform the in take people belongings and formed the decrease government taxes security by deduction for youth and youngs money request which mean hurt a little when lottery waste new Zealand and Australia UK of coarse India
Aslong as they live here and are not tourists
@99NS52J1yr1Y
Yes, as long as they are either working and paying taxes, or are refugees or asylum seekers
@99NRNLN1yr1Y
I don’t know enough about this
@99MV9MX1yr1Y
Yes, so long as they are taking up residency or seeking asylum/ refuge
Yes but only if they are an Irish citizen, refugee or asylum seeker
@99FXK3G1yr1Y
Only if they have an Irish citizenship
@99CCGFB1yr1Y
They should be progressivelly included in welfare schemes the longer they stay in the country or according to a point system
@996S9CP1yr1Y
Yes, if they have been in the country legally for 5 years
@98DWMMM1yr1Y
Yes as long as they can prove that they are actively searching for work. This should be checked up on regularly.
@984C42L1yr1Y
Yes, if their paying taxes.
@983Z5QB1yr1Y
No, but we should still allow refugees and asylum seekers into our country
@983X5HPFianna Fáil1yr1Y
Yes, to refugees, BOTP, asylum seekers (with or awaiting status) and foreign nationals who work and pay taxes
@97Y8SG51yr1Y
Yes for refugees and asylum seekers up to six months, then they need to find work and pay taxes
@97R8Q6Z1yr1Y
Yes, initial payments for refugees and asylum seekers while legal registration is being processed and also to immigrants actively seeking work if/when initial employment was terminated.
@97PZ24H1yr1Y
Yes, in regards to refugees and asylum seekers but they need to have the same regulations that citizens have, and be encouraged to get work as soon as possible.
As for people who immigrate, they should have jobs lined up before entry and since they are paying taxes they should be allowed to have access to social welfare after a period of time.
@9748M281yr1Y
Yes, as long as they are resident in the state or are refugees/seeking asylum
@96ZHD97Fianna Fáil1yr1Y
Yes, but only if they are in acquirance of Irish citizenship
@96ZGXPLIndependent1yr1Y
Only for a limited time, and they must get employment afterwards
If they are unable to work or make below living wage
@96SXSSX1yr1Y
Yes, so long as they have been working for 6 months and paying taxes in the country beforehand. Maybe for a limited amount of time, maybe 4 months.
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...